Coastal Pizza in Yulee

Love it and sad they're now on the island

Great pizza and friendly staff

Our go to pizza place in Yulee. Excellent side salads, and great pizza. They get very busy, an indication of their quality, so going early helps, or call for takeout. Thursday nights after 6 get especially busy due to the popular trivia night.

Really enjoy their pizza.

Excellent white pizza, salad and Italian Sausage sub!

Really great pizza and sandwiches, friendly and accommodating staff that always remembers the parm and red pepper packs and competitive pricing. The atmosphere is quaint and nostalgic. Can't recommend it enough, love it!!

Great pizza and yesterday I had their wings......wow the best wings I ever had. I absolutely cannot express how great the wings with mild sauce and the Blackrock pizza was. The crew is friendly and seem very happy to be there. If your here from out of town it’s a must try.

Why do they burn there pizzas, absolutely the worst pizza anywhere. Store bought frozen pizza tastes better than coastal.

Ordered Wings Pizza And 2 beersFantastic service!The new girl is on point!Wonderful food!Great value!I’m sending EVERYONE here that I know

The food is always great here! The owner is very charismatic and fun to talk to.

Pizza is very good made fresh

Anthony the cook is a great cook! Love his food!

Delicious pizza. Legitimately, this place is delightful.

Great spot highly recommend it 👍

Great pizza , owner and staff : )

Although it was very busy, the service was great and our food came out quickly. The food was great and reasonably priced, I will come back

Very good pizza, saw many locals here. Definitely has a yulee vibe.

We have been here many times. Small homey atmosphere. If you want true Italian real cheese, or an awesome calzone add spinach and pepperoni..

Staff is super great! Pizza is awesome!!

Best pizza in Yulee area bar none. It is a shame they are moving over to the island where there are already 4 or 5 other good pizza joints, but I hope for the best for them!

While there was no server and it was counter service, it was not a big deal. Pizza was very good. Help yourself to drinks. Staff and owner were attentive. Trivia on Thursday's. Gonna give that a try.

Picked up a cheese pizza tonight, ask for it crispy. When she brought it to me she opened the box very quickly and started to ring me up. I opened the box and some of the crust was burnt. The employee said “well you ask for it crispy” and then ask (in an inconvenient way)if I wanted her to make another. A lady waiting for her pizza said that’s not crispy that’s burnt! Anyway didn’t have time to wait for another so I paid full price for a half burnt pizza.

Their salads are like nowhere else, awsome Pizza, owner is a sponsor of local ball teams as well as myself.GO Orioles.Giving Back to the Community.Ted RMasonry Plus

The pizza we had was a very good it was the Margarita Pizza, staff was very friendly. We tought two dollars per topping each was a little high, but would still recommend.

Great lunch, locally-owned. These guys always do a great job & take pride in serving good food. Love it!

Best pizza in North Florida. Always fantastic service. Can't find a better pie in NYC.

There is no other Pizza like this. It's a must if your visiting. We live here and it's an every Friday thing for us.

Salads are really good here my wife says.Pizza is good

It was pizza but in my opinion there are much better pizza places in town.

Good pizza and atmosphere. Not a lot of parking.

Such a friendly place and salad was wonderful.

Great food at reasonable prices...family friendly and relaxed atmosphere!

Coastal Pizza is a local pizzeria with some Italian food on the menu. The pizza is thin crust, and very good. I think their margarita pizza is something special. They currently (2020) have a Tuesday night carry out special, purchase a large specialty pizza and get a free medium cheese pizza.

Great pizza! Quality ingredients, excellent crust. Order at counter for dine in or take out. They get really busy and each one is made from scratch so not a great choice if you're in a hurry at dinner time unless you call ahead for pickup.

My only complaint is no anchovies. Really you have to have anchovies. Tighten up. But great pizza and the baked ziti is the best.

They give you what you Ask For.Great Pizzas

Great Pizza, very busy & popular! Which makes a Longer wait time for your pizza, but it's worth it! Dine in / Pick Up only. Very Casual / no frills, just great pizza! 😊

Fun was good. Service could be improved. No one greets the customers.

Recently relocated to Fernandina Beach and was looking for good pizza....not chain restaurant pizza. We have definitely found it with this place! Called our order in for pick up and still had to wait...not complaining, just a testament as to how good their food is...they were very busy. We will definitely be return customers.

Always good food... Friendly staff..

Great food great people

Used to enjoy eating there, but on 1/4/19 my wife and I arrived at 8:40 and were told they could not serve us because they close at nine. So now we will drive past Coastal and go to Townies who welcomed us in.

It was as close as you can get to NY style pizza without being in NY

This is a review of 3 visits. Since the owner has stepped out of the day to day operations customer service and quality has dropped. My order has been messed up (missing ingredients on staple items). unnecessary wait times for pick up orders. (Nobody in the restaurant or backed up orders) and bad customer service. (Wait staff with attitudes when asked about it. A girl with blue hair in particular.) When I reached out to the owner he wouldn't own it and seemed to tried to validate my review rather than apologizing and taking responsibility. I also refused a discount in the future. As an industry professional I waited three separate visits and reached out to the owner before leaving a review. What I wanted was the same quality and service that was available upon opening a year or so ago. The area and the industry deserves consistency.

Very good pizza. During the weekdays you can order slices any way you want. The slices are huge. When I take my granddaughter they are very attentive. After the second visit they call her by name and they make her pizza first so it has time to cool down before they bring it. My little red headed Creature loves the pizza and gobbles it up.

Skimpy on the toppings

😍😍😍 the quality of their pizza is amazing, fresh ingredients, the sauce is amazing, plenty of cheese! And to top it off, their service is amazing and friendly.

Food is great, friendly atmosphere!

Good food 👍 great service

Great local family run and locally owned. Nothing fancy but very nice service.